Is an “Alliance of Alliances” around AI feasible?
The newly released final report of the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence is rich in recommendations. But operationalizing them may be trickier.
By Jacob Parakilas*
“America is not prepared to defend or compete in the AI era.” The introduction to the final report of the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence released
The report itself covers a wide range of topics related to AI, but its focus (unsurprisingly, given that the commission was created through the 2019 National Defense Authorization Act) is principally on national security implications. There is one particular aspect of the report which is worth a closer examination: its call, in chapter 3, for the U.S. to bring its global military allies and partners together around a common set of AI standards for interoperability and common operational doctrine for the development and use of AI-driven emerging technologies.
The report recommends that the U.S. draw its disparate allies and partners together to retain its AI technological edge over China and Russia. Specifically, it calls for creating an “Atlantic-Pacific Security Technology Partnership,” drawing together the Quad, NATO, the Five Eyes nations and the members of the AI Partnership for Defense, along with other unspecified allies and partners.
But — speaking as a lapsed think tanker — making sweeping policy recommendations is easy. Operationalizing them is less so.
On its face, it makes sense to pursue standardization among military allies. The U.S. has been doing so since the Second World War, when it became the “Arsenal of Democracy” and shipped everything from rations to fighter aircraft to allies across the world fighting very different types of wars. That experience informed American post-war alliances and spoke to the crucial importance of simplifying production and supply chains, not to mention creating uniform performance and training standards to make military personnel capable of fighting together efficiently and effectively. As a result, U.S.-led standards are prevalent across the militaries of the developed world. As one example, NATO (largely at the urging of the U.S.) standardized rifle and machine-gun ammunition around the 5.56 mm and 7.62 mm rounds. Those remain the standard calibers for not only NATO member states but countries around the world aligned with the U.S. It is, after all, much cheaper and easier to buy into an existing standard than to create a new one.
But software is not a rifle bullet. Artificially intelligent software, in particular, is inherently adaptive and flexible. And American allies have hugely divergent laws and public views of surveillance and the legitimate role of technology in daily life. To even agree on a relatively basic set of standards between nations as differently oriented as Germany, Japan, India, Israel and Singapore — just to name a few — will be an enormously complex and politically fraught endeavor.
That political element should not be underrated as an obstacle to the proposed partnership. The report identifies China as the prime competitor and potential threat; there is little mention of potential cooperation on AI with the PRC. Russia, too, is listed as an adversary, primarily around the idea of AI-enabled disinformation campaigns. But many of the countries listed as necessary partners in the Partnership do not share the ascendant American geostrategic outlook. Will India, with its fairly close political and military ties with Russia, want to be part of an effort directed in part at limiting Russian influence? Will Israel, which maintains strong political ties with Russia and a degree of industrial and commercial exchange with China? Will EU nations, whose approach to China has caused significant consternation in Washington at times, want to sign on to an effort that is cast in explicitly national security terms — especially given Washington’s recent and questionable use of national security justifications in its approach to trade policy?
Furthermore, there is the question of whether the putative members of this body will be interested in working with each other. The American strategy in the Cold War was to build a hub and spokes model of alliances: the U.S. would support European countries through NATO, and separately support a set of allies in the Asia-Pacific region, all in the name of containing Communism. The success of the strategy did not rely on bringing Asia and Europe together. But the U.S. position now is far less dominant than it was in the late 1940s, when the U.S. was the only feasible non-Soviet backer for European and Asian nations still struggling to rebuild from the shattering damage of the Second World War. Absent some clearer and more present danger, the U.S. needs to offer more meaningful incentives to rebuild and reform its alliance structures around a technological challenge — and it is not clear from this report what those might be.
None of this is to suggest that the potential threats posed by artificial intelligence aren’t real or present or growing. But to suggest that the U.S. circa 2021 can simply rally a sizeable fraction of the world around its agenda betrays a certain naivety about the geopolitical order into which AI systems are going to be deployed.
*Jacob Parakilas is an author, consultant, and analyst working on U.S. foreign policy and international security.
Source: thediplomat.com
The post Is an “Alliance of Alliances” around AI feasible? appeared first on ARMYNOW.NET.
- Δημοφιλέστερες Ειδήσεις Κατηγορίας Blogs
- ΓΙΑ ΤΗΝ ΕΜΦΑΝΙΣΗ ΤΗΣ στην Ρόδο! ΚΡΑΖΟΥΝ ΑΓΡΙΑ την Κατ. Σακελλαροπούλου...
- Διαδίκτυο Απόρρητο: Πώς θα προστατεύετε τα προσωπικά σας δεδομένα σύμφωνα με ειδικούς
- ΗΠΑ: Παγκόσμια συγκίνηση για την 7χρονη που πουλά λεμονάδες για να κάνει εγχείρηση στον εγκέφαλο
- EΟΡΤΟΛΟΓΙΟ ΠΟΙΟΙ ΓΙΟΡΤΑΖΟΥΝ ΣΗΜΕΡΑ 7 ΜΑΡΤΙΟΥ- ΚΥΡΙΑΚΗ ΤΩΝ ΑΠΟΚΡΕΩ
- Δόξας: χαμός στο προφίλ του στα social media
- Θεσσαλονίκη: Συνελήφθησαν οι δήθεν “τεχνικοί” που άρπαξαν 80.000 ευρώ από ηλικιωμένη
- Παπαζάχος: «Περιμένουμε μεγάλο μετασεισμό στην Ελασσόνα»
- MasterChef: Αποχώρηση με ανατροπή από το ριάλιτι - Συγκίνηση και κλάματα στον εξώστη - ΒΙΝΤΕΟ
- ΠΩΣ ΤΟ ΓΝΩΡΙΖΕΙ; Η ΓΕΡΜΑΝΙΚΗ "ΤUI" κάνει (από τώρα) κρατήσεις για τα μέσα Μαΐου στη χώρα μας...
- Ευαγγέλιο Κυριακής και Απόστολος Κυριακής 7 Μαρτίου 2021 – Όσιος Λαυρέντιος
- Δημοφιλέστερες Ειδήσεις Armynow
- US may field new fighter by FY 2029
- China’s Destroyer Fleet: The Next Great Naval Threat?
- Veterans application for civilian careers: 3 easy tips to help you focus your post-military resume
- NATO Deputy Secretary General highlights NATO’s role as transatlantic forum for collaboration on emerging technologies
- No ‘New Cold War’ as US bombers move into Norwegian base
- Is an “Alliance of Alliances” around AI feasible?
- Τελευταία Νέα Armynow
- Is an “Alliance of Alliances” around AI feasible?
- US may field new fighter by FY 2029
- No ‘New Cold War’ as US bombers move into Norwegian base
- Veterans application for civilian careers: 3 easy tips to help you focus your post-military resume
- NATO Deputy Secretary General highlights NATO’s role as transatlantic forum for collaboration on emerging technologies
- China’s Destroyer Fleet: The Next Great Naval Threat?
- Turkey and Russia remain at odds as Libya edges towards a political settlement
- DoD space agency to award multiple contracts for up to 150 satellites
- Building a China strategy starts by answering these questions
- Desert Storm Veteran in new battle with prostate cancer
- Τελευταία Νέα Κατηγορίας Blogs
- Κορονοϊός: «Διασωληνώνουμε ολόκληρες οικογένειες» – Δραματική έκκληση από Γκάγκα
- Χιλή: Δώρισε 40.000 δόσεις εμβολίων σε Ισημερινό και Παραγουάη
- Η διαχειρίσιμη ύφεση και οι ισχνές πιθανότητες για ανάκαμψη το 2021
- Κορονοϊός: «Βόμβα» λοιμωξιολόγων- «Παράταση του lockdown έως τον Απρίλιο»
- Κυριακή των Απόκρεω: τι τρώνε σήμερα
- ΕΜΥ Καιρός: Έκτακτο δελτίο για σήμερα Κυριακή 7 Μαρτίου-Κυριακή των Απόκρεω
- Θεσσαλονίκη: Συνελήφθησαν οι δήθεν “τεχνικοί” που άρπαξαν 80.000 ευρώ από ηλικιωμένη
- Απόφαση: Διαδικασίες υποβολής προτάσεων των ΕΛΚΕ για την υλοποίηση έργων/προγραμμάτων
- Τι λένε τ’ άστρα και τα ζώδια (7/3/2021)
- Απογείωσε το χουχούλιασμα κάτω από την κουβέρτα, δίνοντας βάση στο καθάρισμά της